user icon
user icon

Montoya and Villeneuve question Kubica comeback

  • Published on 16 Nov 2017 12:10
  • comments 7
  • By: Rob Veenstra

Two former F1 drivers have cast doubt on Robert Kubica's ability to successfully return to formula one next year. More authoritative sources are now joining French broadcaster Canal Plus in claiming that after a test for the Pole in Abu Dhabi, Kubica will be announced as Lance Stroll's teammate at Williams for 2018.

Williams co-founder and former technical boss Patrick Head backed the team's decision to give Kubica a test after the forthcoming F1 finale. "Robert was one of the best drivers in F1 of recent years," he is quoted by Finland's Turun Sanomat. "Only he knows how ready he is for the challenge. He was seriously injured, and Williams wants to find out what his situation is. If he is able to perform from a physical point of view, he is a very good choice," Head added.

Brazil's Globo claims that while other drivers were considered to replace Felipe Massa next year, Kubica's talent and a reported EUR 8 million in sponsorship collated in part by co-manager Nico Rosberg clinched the deal. But not everyone is convinced.

1997 world champion Jacques Villeneuve thinks Kubica's permanently injured right arm means the 32-year-old is a safety risk. "It's not just about the test where he has to get out of a stationary car with the Halo, which is already quite hard," the Canadian told Germany's Auto Bild. "What about a start where he has to abruptly dodge an object? I doubt you can do that with one hand. From my own experience I know you cannot," Villeneuve said.

"I think the FIA needs to think carefully about how they can be 100 per cent sure that Robert is able to avoid accidents. Kubica himself should also think carefully about whether he wants to. This is not about laptimes, he also has a responsibility to his colleagues. The same is true of Williams. If there is a serious accident, the responsibility will be great," Villeneuve added.

Another former Williams driver, Juan Pablo Montoya, agrees. "Honestly, it's a joke," said the Colombian. "I'm sure Robert is no longer 100 per cent capable of pushing a formula one car to the limit."

The media report claims current F1 drivers may raise the issue of Kubica's apparent F1 return in the FIA briefing in Abu Dhabi next Friday. (GMM)

Replies (7)

Login to reply
  • kngrthr

    Posts: 203

    before flappy paddle gear shifting, drivers used to take the right hand off the wheel to change gear while dodging debris at the start.
    so the one hand issue is nonsense.

    • + 0
    • Nov 16 2017 - 12:56
  • Niids

    Posts: 43

    Kubica won WRC2 championship, also few WRC stages. Only issue cloud be his hand's endurence, no his reflex. Villeneuve has to hate Kubica since 2006.

    • + 0
    • Nov 16 2017 - 15:30
  • Marci

    Posts: 1

    Hahahah b...hit

    TRY THIS
    youtu.be/YgOxzH9uBbM

    Best Wishes for You Montoya - shame on You

    • + 0
    • Nov 16 2017 - 15:51
  • Kean

    Posts: 692

    For a long time now, I haven't put much stock in Villeneuve's opinion, he seems to be a bit of a douche. His opinion regarding Kubica should be ignored since he hates the guy. And Montoya, I really don't care what he thinks either. Didn't he leave F1 under "cry baby" circumstances?

    • + 1
    • Nov 16 2017 - 18:00
  • Couple of guys who only have criticism for anything and everything related to Formula 1. Useless.

    • + 1
    • Nov 16 2017 - 18:31
  • Barron

    Posts: 625

    Well, they know more about it than we armchair experts that’s for sure! Although I’d love Robert to make an emotional return to F1, I too would be worried. These two guys are only openly saying what millions are thinking.

    • + 0
    • Nov 17 2017 - 10:11
  • Sour grapes from two 'has-beens' seeking attention.

    • + 0
    • Nov 17 2017 - 11:24

BE Grand Prix of Belgium

Local time 

BE Grand Prix of Belgium

Local time 

Related news

Test calendar

Circuit de Catalunya - Winter testing

Circuit de Catalunya - Winter testing

See full test schedule

Give your opinion!

Will Bottas challenge Hamilton for the world championship in 2020?

World Championship standings 2020

Show full world champion standings

Driver profile

  • Team Alfa Romeo Racing
  • Points 1
  • Podiums 0
  • Grand Prix 21
  • Country PL
  • Date of b. Dec 7 1984 (36)
  • Place of b. Krakau, PL
  • Weight 72 kg
  • Length 1.83 m
Show full profile

Team profile

Show full profile

Formula 1 Calendar - 2020

Date
Grand Prix
Circuit
-
Spain
-
Spain
3 - Jul 5 2020
Austria
10 - Jul 12 2020
Austria
17 - Jul 19 2020
Hungary
31 - Aug 2 2020
United Kingdom
7 - Aug 9 2020
United Kingdom
14 - Aug 16 2020
Spain
28 - Aug 30 2020
Belgium
4 - Sep 6 2020
Italy
11 - Sep 13 2020
Italy
25 - Sep 27 2020
Russian
9 - Oct 11 2020
Germany
23 - Oct 25 2020
Portugal
31 - Nov 1 2020
Italy
13 - Nov 15 2020
Turkey
27 - Nov 29 2020
Bahrain
11 - Dec 13 2020
United Arab Emirates
See full schedule

Formula 1 Calendar - 2020

Date
Grand Prix & Circuit
3 - Jul 5 2020
Austria Red Bull Ring
10 - Jul 12 2020
Austria Red Bull Ring
17 - Jul 19 2020
Hungary Hungaroring
31 - Aug 2 2020
United Kingdom Silverstone
7 - Aug 9 2020
United Kingdom Silverstone
14 - Aug 16 2020
28 - Aug 30 2020
4 - Sep 6 2020
Italy Monza
11 - Sep 13 2020
Italy Mugello
25 - Sep 27 2020
Russian Sochi Autodrom
9 - Oct 11 2020
Germany Nurburgring
23 - Oct 25 2020
31 - Nov 1 2020
13 - Nov 15 2020
Turkey Istanbul Park
27 - Nov 29 2020
11 - Dec 13 2020
United Arab Emirates Yas Marina Circuit
See full schedule
show sidebar