user icon

Regulations prevented Mercedes from helping Hamilton over engine stall fears in Hungary

  • Published on 23 Jul 2020 16:50
  • comments 5
  • By: Fergal Walsh

Mercedes was not able to assist Lewis Hamilton amid his fears that his engine would stall at the start of the race in Hungary last Sunday due to rules regarding communication on the formation lap.

Before the commencement of the grand prix in Budapest, Hamilton took to his radio to tell Mercedes: “The engine keeps sounding like it's going to stall.”

Article 27.1 of the sporting regulations states “the driver must drive the car alone and unaided”, a rule that Haas fell afoul of when it instructed Kevin Magnussen and Romain Grosjean to pit for dry tyres at the end of the formation lap.

As a result, both drivers had ten seconds added to their total race time at the chequered flag.

Hamilton encountered no problems during the race start, with Mercedes knowing that there was no issue with the engine - however it couldn't calm his fears, or it risked receiving a similar penalty. 

Speaking in Mercedes' F1 debrief video, the team's trackside engineering director Andrew Shovlin said: “Lewis reported a problem on the formation lap where he said he thought the engine was going to stall.

“What it actually was, was a sensor issue that was only affecting the engine around the idle controls, so when he was sat there waiting to go off on the formation lap.

“Now, it wasn’t a problem, it wasn’t going to stall and there is a protection that will actually stop the engine from stalling anyway if you were in that situation.

“But we couldn’t tell him it was OK and that’s because of the rules that prevent you talking to the driver during that entire formation lap. So, we knew it was fine, but he had to worry a bit for the next few minutes until he got off the line.”

Bottas' false start caused by reaction to steering wheel lights

While Hamilton was able to move off the line cleanly, his teammate Valtteri Bottas moved before the start lights went out. He then came to a complete stop before setting off again.

The Finn avoided a penalty for jumping the start, with Shovlin confirming that Bottas' initial reaction was from a light change on his steering wheel dashboard.

“Valtteri’s issue was actually that he reacted to one of the lights on his dash that flickered,” Shovlin said. “And that’s because he practices starts using his steering wheel over the weekend and to simulate the lights going out for the start grid, the lights on the dash on the steering wheel go out.

“And that was why he reacted to it, it distracted him. Now, luckily, he was able to pull the clutch and avoid a jump start. Now, there’s an automatic system that will detect where the car is and when it has left the grid box.

“And the car can sit within a reasonably wide position on that grid box without detecting it, and because Valtteri hadn’t moved far he was still within range. So, the system didn’t think it was a jump start because he was still within his box when the lights actually went out.

“What it did do, though, was cost him an awful lot of places because resetting and getting ready to go meant that everyone else was off and around him by the time he was getting up to speed.”

Replies (5)

Login to reply
  • So again, why is it that Haas didn't get penalized for being called to the pits during the Hungarian Grand Prix? I don't think they will, but I just haven't understood why that call wasn't a violation of Article 27.1

    • + 0
    • Jul 23 2020 - 19:16
    • Snooky

      Posts: 121

      I think because the team told the drivers to start on the dry tyre which gave them an advantage at the start. I don’t agree with it because the rule was meant to stop advice on clutch positions etc. Even though this is done prior to the race, it’s up to the driver to remember and execute during. The Haas cars gained an advantage off the start by changing to Dry tyres under instruction not their own decision

      • + 0
      • Jul 23 2020 - 21:29
    • I thought HAAS did actually get penalised - 10 seconds.

      • + 0
      • Jul 24 2020 - 00:59
    • My apologies everyone, you're right @greatbigdong (that name lol). They were penalised. Somehow I missed that.

      • + 2
      • Jul 24 2020 - 02:34
  • Kinda think the rule is flawed. Stalling is one thing drivers definitely should be helped with..

    • + 0
    • Jul 24 2020 - 09:45

BE Grand Prix of Belgium

Local time 

BE Grand Prix of Belgium

Local time 

Related news

Test calendar

Circuit de Catalunya - Winter testing

Circuit de Catalunya - Winter testing

See full test schedule

Give your opinion!

Will Bottas challenge Hamilton for the world championship in 2020?

World Championship standings 2020

Show full world champion standings

Driver profile

  • Team Mercedes
  • Points 2,317
  • Podiums 96
  • Grand Prix 119
  • Country United Kingdom
  • Date of b. Jan 7 1985 (36)
  • Place of b. Tewin, United Kingdom
  • Weight 68 kg
  • Length 1.74 m
Show full profile

Team profile

Show full profile

Formula 1 Calendar - 2021

Date
Grand Prix
Circuit
-
Bahrain
26 - Mar 28
Bahrain
16 - Apr 18
Italy
7 - May 9
Spain
21 - May 23
Monaco
4 - Jun 6
Azerbaijan
11 - Jun 13
Canada
25 - Jun 27
France
2 - Jul 4
Austria
16 - Jul 18
United Kingdom
30 - Aug 1
Hungary
27 - Aug 29
Belgium
3 - Sep 5
Netherlands
10 - Sep 12
Italy
24 - Sep 26
Russian
1 - Oct 3
Singapore
8 - Oct 10
Japan
22 - Oct 24
United States of America
29 - Oct 31
Mexico
5 - Nov 7
Brazil
19 - Nov 21
Australia
3 - Dec 5
Saudi Arabia
10 - Dec 12
United Arab Emirates
See full schedule

Formula 1 Calendar - 2021

Date
Grand Prix & Circuit
26 - Mar 28
16 - Apr 18
7 - May 9
21 - May 23
Monaco Monte Carlo
4 - Jun 6
Azerbaijan Baku City Circuit
11 - Jun 13
25 - Jun 27
France Paul Ricard
2 - Jul 4
Austria Red Bull Ring
16 - Jul 18
United Kingdom Silverstone
30 - Aug 1
Hungary Hungaroring
27 - Aug 29
3 - Sep 5
Netherlands Circuit Zandvoort
10 - Sep 12
Italy Monza
24 - Sep 26
Russian Sochi Autodrom
1 - Oct 3
8 - Oct 10
22 - Oct 24
United States of America Circuit of the Americas
29 - Oct 31
5 - Nov 7
Brazil Interlagos
19 - Nov 21
Australia Albert Park
3 - Dec 5
Saudi Arabia Jeddah Street Circuit
10 - Dec 12
United Arab Emirates Yas Marina Circuit
See full schedule
show sidebar