Grosjean struggling to understand penalty decision

<< Return to the news list

Grosjean struggling to understand penalty decision

Published on 12 Nov 2017 21:12
10
By: Fergal Walsh

Romain Grosjean is struggling to understand why the stewards handed him a 10-second stop-go penalty for causing a collision. On the opening lap of the Brazilian Grand Prix, Grosjean lost the rear of his car heading into Turn 6, and took Esteban Ocon out of the race.

The stewards deemed him guilty and handed him a penalty. After the race, Grosjean questioned the stewards' decision, claiming that he had a puncture and that was the reason for his sudden spin into Ocon.

"The only thing I can say about the opening lap is that I got massively hit in turn one," Grosjean said. "I believe I had a puncture on the rear left. I got to turn six and lost the car, and I think it was just the puncture. Getting a penalty on top of that – I'm not super happy with it. I want to see the footage.

"The positive from the race is that the last stint on the supersoft, the car felt amazing. Even though we had massive floor damage, it felt really good. We now need to understand why it felt so good and move on to Abu Dhabi."

I'm sorry for @OconEsteban , but with a puncture (from being hit into turn 1) it's rather difficult to control the car... Personally struggling to understand the penalty though!
— Romain Grosjean (@RGrosjean) November 12, 2017

krommenaas

Posts: 155

I can't wrap my head around how Grosjean gets a penalty and Magnussen doesn't. If Magnussen, who deliberately turned into Stoffel, does not get a penalty, then how can Grosjean get one when he clearly just made a mistake or had bad luck with the puncture?

1
Nov 13 2017 - 10:46

F1 News Romain Grosjean Esteban Ocon

Replies (10)

mbmwe36

Posts: 533
I agree. I would chalk that up to a racing incident. Yes, he went into that corner guns blazing, but it could've easily worked out.
And if he did deserve a punishment, why 10 seconds? Usually people get 5, even when they're clearly at fault.
- + 0
- Nov 12 2017 - 22:11
boudy

Posts: 1,168
Who knows the stewarding has been inconsistent this year. Bottas and Raikkonen should have penalties along somewhere but they didn't. Other drivers got penalties on a whim.
- + 0
- Nov 13 2017 - 07:33
- calle.itw
  
  Posts: 8,527
  Agreed, they really need to sort that out.
  + 0
  
  Nov 13 2017 - 07:50
- mcbhargav
  
  Posts: 1,332
  Should automate this job, based on predetermined ( but further expanded) rules. If automation fails, at least its fair for all ;).
  + 0
  
  Nov 14 2017 - 00:04
FatMike

Posts: 153
Esteban got Grosjean'd. Wasn't this the same penalty as they gave Verstappen when he took out Ricciardo in Hungary earlier this year?
- + 0
- Nov 13 2017 - 07:39
krommenaas

Posts: 155
I can't wrap my head around how Grosjean gets a penalty and Magnussen doesn't. If Magnussen, who deliberately turned into Stoffel, does not get a penalty, then how can Grosjean get one when he clearly just made a mistake or had bad luck with the puncture?
- + 1
- Nov 13 2017 - 10:46
- Bhurt
  
  Posts: 320
  Agree completely.
  + 0
  
  Nov 13 2017 - 14:12
Barron

Posts: 625
Ah Kevin the Barbarian! F1’s new Destroyer...? As for Romain, well <shrug> he’s just a Lettuce n’est ce pas? ?
- + 0
- Nov 13 2017 - 11:38
ajpennypacker

Posts: 2,475
Haas has the worst driver pairing in F1. That's all that seems clear to me. The stewarding... yeah needs some work. But not as much as Haas driver pairing.
- + 0
- Nov 13 2017 - 19:15
f1ski

Posts: 726
Just rematched the incident grosjeans tailed stepped out after his front wheel touched icons car. Grosjean doesn't realize what he is doing in the heat of the race. He had the same issues when he was a rookie always in crashes blaming others. When receives a blue flag he tries to race the leaders. His 10 second penalty is more because of his history this season
- + 0
- Nov 13 2017 - 20:02